Which are the Best Rated Insurance Companies?

Feb 10, 2025
Categories: General · News · Staebler Insurance
Staebler blog logo

A Staebler Insurance partner, RATESDOTCA Group, commissioned an auto insurance study to share which insurance companies ranked highest in customer satisfaction.

As an insurance brokerage, Staebler is very pleased to see several of the companies we represent rank in the top three in several categories.

It’s important to us that we continue to offer insurance products, including auto insurance, from companies that share similar values including an emphasis on an excellent customer experience.

In the best overall insurance company category, CAA Insurance and Gore Mutual Insurance were the top two companies. Meanwhile for best auto insurance claims experience, Northbridge Insurance and CAA were ranked one and two, respectively. You can view the full rating lists below.

We want to hear from you!

Did you know that the Staebler Insurance website launched insurance company pages that allows you to rate your experience with them? This feedback is valuable for us to share with our company partners to help continue to improve services and offer you the best insurance experience possible.

A list of many of the companies Staebler Insurance represents can be found here: Staebler’s Insurance Companies

Simply click on your company to learn more about them and to leave a review.

Please do not include any personal or sensitive information in your review. If there is a specific issue you’re experiencing that is ongoing, please do not hesitate to reach out to your Staebler Insurance Broker to see if they can help resolve the situation.

Here are the results of the RATESDOTCA study:

Best Overall Insurance Company

  1. CAA Insurance Company
  2. Gore Mutual Insurance
  3. Intact Insurance

Best Auto Insurance Claims Experience

  1. Northbridge Insurance
  2. CAA Insurance Company
  3. Intact

Best Insurance Policy Documents

  1. CAA Insurance Company
  2. Gore Mutual Insurance
  3. Economical Insurance (Definity)

Best Insurance Billing Statements

  1. CAA Insurance Company
  2. Gore Mutual Insurance
  3. Intact

. . .
Staebler Insurance is a general insurance broker specializing in car insurance, home insurance, small business insurance, and commercial insurance. Staebler Insurance Brokers proudly serve Kitchener, Waterloo, Cambridge, Guelph, Stratford, Listowel, Fergus, Elora, Wellington County, Perth County, Waterloo Region, the Greater Toronto Area, Golden Horseshoe, Niagara Region, and all over beautiful Ontario, Canada. Get a Quote to get started today.

0 Comments

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Related Posts

Ontario Police Collaborate to Bust Niagara-Area Chop Shop

Facebook said to File for Mega IPO

Facebook is expected to submit paperwork to regulators on Wednesday morning for a US$5-billion initial public offering and has selected Morgan Stanley and four other bookrunners to handle the mega-IPO, sources close to the deal told IFR.  For more informtion on this...

read more
Ontario Police Collaborate to Bust Niagara-Area Chop Shop

Family won’t get Insurance Payout

No claim made; 'Accident' doesn't meet compensation criteria Despite some media reports the Shafia family, might receive payouts under Quebec's no-fault insurance system. The board says, there will be no payout. Click here to get the whole story.

read more
Ontario Police Collaborate to Bust Niagara-Area Chop Shop

2011 Annual Staebler Christmas Party

The Staebler Team got together for our annual Christmas Party celebration on Saturday, December 10th. Check out the pictures by clicking here and don't forget to tag the people you recognize! Make sure you like Staebler Insurance while your visiting our Facebook...

read more
Ontario Police Collaborate to Bust Niagara-Area Chop Shop

Canada Post Strike

Well it happened... the post office workers went on strike as of Thursday, June 2, 2011 at midnight. All of our insurance providers have a plan in place to provide the best possible service during this set back. YOUR POLICY DOCUMENTS If you are renewing soon, you may...

read more
Ontario Police Collaborate to Bust Niagara-Area Chop Shop

Signing The Strings

The story starts when Charlie Fraser, a friend of Judy MacKenzie's, was diagnosed with cancer. Charlie was known to his friends as Charlie "Pride" Fraser after his favourite artist, Charley Pride. Charlie really enjoyed playing his guitar and he wanted Judy to learn...

read more
Ontario Police Collaborate to Bust Niagara-Area Chop Shop

Staebler In Print

The Ontario Broker: Click Here to read the July 2010 article featuring Kim & Stephen Philpott, President & Chairman of Staebler Insurance. TruLife Magazine: Click Here to read the November/December 2009 article featuring Staebler Insurance Brokers.

read more
Ontario Police Collaborate to Bust Niagara-Area Chop Shop

Our Planet Earth

We're paperless! It's important to us to do our part in conserving resources. In 2006 we began a process in our personal insurance department to become paperless. Today, most of our insurance companies suppress our copy of your policy documents and we receive data...

read more